Email
Peter Dutton and Anthony Albanese ought to be careful calling each other liars, while the Teals are becoming more known as bastions of hypocrisy than integrity writes Joe Hildebrand.
View in browser 17th April 2025
 

image

Joe Hildebrand
Federal election correspondent

One of the cardinal rules of politics is that you don’t call your opponent a liar. This isn’t due to some ancient and noble code of honour but because in politics everyone tells untruths, mistruths, half-truths and flat-out porkies.

If telling lies disqualified you from politics our parliament would be empty.

Even in those august chambers the word “lie” rarely rears its ugly head. Instead the capital crime is euphemistically termed “misleading the parliament”.

But desperate times call for desperate measures and with today the last day of business before the nation breaks for Easter, the Coalition has loaded its cannon with the L-bomb and is firing at Albanese with abandon.

While Peter Dutton kept up the polite pretence during the second debate last night — saying only that the PM had “a problem with the truth” — campaign spokesman James Patterson unleashed, even setting up an “Albanese live lie tracker” online.

“He’s lied about the Coalition’s record on health, he’s lied about the Coalition’s record on education, he has even lied about falling off the stage,” he said.

“But the lie he told tonight about negative gearing is the most bald-faced lie he’s told in this campaign so far.”

This related to the PM’s claim that his government hadn’t got modelling done on negative gearing changes. Instead this modelling apparently emerged unbidden from the Treasury, which if true could mark the first confirmed evidence of initiative being shown by a government bureaucracy.

And so one man’s lie is another man’s tactical obfuscation.

Either way it’s a sign of how desperate this campaign has become and that whether you’re throwing accusations or copping them, politics is, at its heart, a dirty game.

imageMark Knight's take on the leaders' debate. Check out more election cartoons here

But lo! What light through yonder window breaks? It is the east, and the Teals are the sun!

The Teal “independents” entered parliament en masse last election, bankrolled by an outfit called Climate 200 convened by billionaire climate activist Simon Holmes a Court.

As well as climate, their key platform was integrity in politics and their moral posturing quickly came to define them.

Among their haughty crusading was even an attack on the dark political art of “push-polling”, which is structuring a poll and its questions in such a way that the respondent is effectively bound to answer in the way the pollster wants them to.

CLICK HERE FOR JOE HILDEBRAND'S FULL ANALYSIS

Election update
Dirty games: Lies, Teals and the art of tactical obfuscation
Peter Dutton and Anthony Albanese ought to be careful calling each other liars, while the Teals are becoming more known as bastions of hypocrisy than integrity writes Joe Hildebran...
READ MORE  
14 battleground seats too close to call as Dutton takes fight to PM
An exclusive new poll reveals Australia is almost certainly tracking towards a minority government as Peter Dutton takes the fight to Anthony Albanese in 14 key seats now too close...
READ MORE  
Insults fly as Dutton goes on the attack over negative gearing
Peter Dutton claims Labor has a secret plan to abolish negative gearing, while Anthony Albanese has questioned whether his opponent believes in gravity. LIVE UPDATES
READ MORE  

VIDEO OF THE DAY

image

Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has been accused of lying over Labor’s plans for negative gearing and capital gains tax during a debate with Opposition Leader Peter Dutton.

 WATCH THE VIDEO HERE

image

Read more
What Australians really think of Donald Trump
A new poll has revealed who Australians back out of Anthony Albanese and Peter Dutton to handle President Donald Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping.
READ MORE  
WATCH: Labor launches diss rap track saying ‘you’re still full of ....’
Labor has released its own cringeworthy diss track despite Anthony Albanese earlier this week ruling out hopes of a federal politics rap feud this election. SEE THE VIDEO
READ MORE  
Bolt: Forget Labor’s spin, the Russians are coming to help China’s dictatorship
The last thing our government needed in this election campaign was proof that war was coming our way but a hostile Russian-Chinese alliance is gradually surrounding us.
READ MORE  
Dutton accuses PM of neg gearing changes; Greens blast handouts
Peter Dutton has claimed Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has a plan to bring in place negative gearing changes as Greens leader Adam Bandt slammed tax handouts that’ll leave renter...
READ MORE  
‘I’m no scientist’: Seven moments and zingers in leaders’ clash
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese and Peter Dutton have faced-off and battlelines were drawn. See the key moments.
READ MORE  
Doom and dependency: What went wrong in Albo v Dutton showdown
The absence of petty back-and-forths between Anthony Albanese and Peter Dutton in the ABC leaders’ debate made their differences clear, writes James Morrow.
READ MORE  
Pressure mounts on Albo to explain Russia-Indonesia debacle
Experts are calling on the Prime Minister to explain what his government has done to counter Moscow’s growing ties to Indonesia, one of our closest geographical neighbours.
READ MORE  
LISTEN NOW: What’s on Teal MP Zoe Daniel’s Spotify list
We have asked Australia’s MPs what their top five songs are on the election trail and Teal Independent MP Zoe Daniel has revealed what’s on her list. Listen now.
READ MORE  
‘Extraordinary decision’: Senator slams ABC over Bob Katter doco
A Queensland senator has called for an investigation into the ABC’s decision to air a documentary profiling maverick MP Bob Katter in the lead up to the federal election arguing th...
READ MORE  
Best of our election race cartoons
These are the best illustrations from our cartoonists who capture the funny side of what’s going on in the federal election race. SEE THE PICTURES
READ MORE  
Question now isn’t can Dutton win a majority, it’s can he win his job
If the polls are right, even a Dutton minority government looks beyond reach. Now it’s about how many seats he needs to win if he is to keep his post, writes James Campbell. VOTE N...
READ MORE  
Dutton’s tradie fix – pay junior apprentices as they finish school
The Coalition has announced a $260m plan targeting Aussie teenagers and apprentices, as well as opening a series of new technical schools.
READ MORE  
‘Parasite’: Indigenous candidate targeted by white supremacists
Macnamara Liberal hopeful Benson Saulo has been called a “f*****g parasite”, had signs vandalised with swastikas and billboards defaced in racist and anti-Semitic attacks.
READ MORE  
Greens move to extend subsidised IVF to gay couples, surrogates
The plan would extend already-announced Labor subsidies to open the door for any couple or person seeking to have a child but cannot do so physically to use altruistic surrogacy.
READ MORE  
Tony Abbott backs Dutton to win ‘miracle’ election
Former Prime Minister Tony Abbott has revealed why he has waved off Peter Dutton’s dismal polling results, holding out hope for a ‘miracle’ win for the Opposition leader.
READ MORE  
‘Overblown’: Mundine slams Indigenous ABC role as ‘waste’
Indigenous leader Warren Mundine has slammed the ABC for creating a new role saying it’s a “waste of time” which “doesn’t really help Aboriginal people.”
READ MORE  

Newsletter

AS NEEDED
Breaking News Alert
Never miss a story that matters to you. Get informed as important news breaks in SA and around the world.
Newsletter sign-up   ▸

Newsletter

DAILY
Sport Daily
Love your sport? Catch up with fresh news and exclusive reports every morning.
Newsletter sign-up   ▸

Newsletter

Every Tuesday
SA Business Journal
Your weekly digest of the stories that matter to South Australian businesses and consumers.
Newsletter sign-up   ▸
The Advertiser app: SA’s best news now has daily recipes too
The Advertiser’s app for smartphones and tablets is the best way to stay in touch with the news in South Australia – and now we can inspire your cooking and baking, too.
READ MORE