Do The IRS Crypto Tax Letters Violate Taxpayer Rights?

By Peter Chawaga

Earlier this week, crypto tax preparation service CoinTracker shared news that its users were receiving letters from the Internal Revenue Service warning them that they may have misreported their crypto transactions to the agency.

The post included comments from r/Bitcoin indicating that crypto holders were receiving IRS Letters 6173, 6174 and 6174-A. The agency had sent out 10,000 of these letters last summer as well.

As in 2019, Letters 6174 and 6174-A are “no action” letters alerting taxpayers about crypto tax filing obligations in general, in case the taxpayer realizes they may have misreported. IRS Letter 6173 actually requires a taxpayer response by an included date, or else the IRA will scrutinize their tax account.

Though the notices might be confusing, there is little reason for bitcoin investors to be seriously worried that today is the day that the government comes for us.

“If you received one of these letters and didn’t report cryptocurrency transactions on your tax return, then there’s no reason to fret, so long as you submit an amended tax return,” Bitcoin Magazine reported in 2019. “But you may have received one of these letters even if you have accurately reported your cryptocurrency gains in your latest round of taxes. If you fall into the latter category, there’s probably even less reason to worry. The IRS is just testing the waters and using its findings as a learning experience.”

But the issuance of the letters should irk Bitcoiners nonetheless. As Coin Center’s Neeraj Agrawal highlighted on Twitter, the IRS Taxpayer Advocate Service (TAS) has called for an end to such issuances. 

The TAS is an independence organization within the IRS that’s tasked with ensuring that every taxpayer is treated fairly and understands their rights. In a report to Congress on its objectives for the fiscal year 2021, the TAS called for an end to “soft letters” (specifically IRS Letter 6173) that replicate IRS examinations without the requisite taxpayer rights protections.

“What is disturbing about soft Letter 6173 is that it specifically addresses taxpayers who believe they are compliant and imposes unreasonable burdens on them outside the protection of an examination,” TAS reported. “The IRS has stated that Letter 6173 is not an examination and therefore the IRS is not required to follow the examination guidance or provide taxpayers the rights afforded them in an examination. Yet, Letter 6173 fails to inform taxpayers that the letter is not part of an examination and as written appears to be a threat directed at taxpayers who believe they are compliant.”

The report went on to point out that the IRS does not require some of the information it asks for in the letter via an actual tax return, thus mimicking an actual tax examination and undermining taxpayer rights and protections.

Finally, the report notes that the IRS Letters may be outright misleading or confusing. 

“Letter 6173, like Letters 6174 and 6174-A, also addresses taxpayers who may have failed to include virtual currency on their return or who incorrectly reported the appropriate virtual currency tax consequences,” per the report. “The letters encourage the taxpayer to file an amended return or file a delinquent return. The letters fail to provide taxpayers with information about the application or assertion of penalties or interest should they ignore — or follow — their encouragement.”

The TAS promises to continue working to remove burdens imposed on taxpayers through such soft letters, but in the meantime, it appears that the IRS does not mind scaring, confusing or otherwise violating the rights of taxpayers who report cryptocurrencies. And as an agency for a government that has often demonstrated broad misunderstanding and outright antagonism toward Bitcoin, this shouldn’t be much of a surprise.

Bitcoin News Roundup

Mathew D’Souza, Bitcoin Pioneer, Dies At 29

Mathew D’Souza, the founder and CEO of Blockware Solutions and Blockware Mining and the manager of the Blockchain Opportunity Fund, died on August 21, 2020 after a seven-year battle with leukemia. He was 29 years old. D’Souza was an outspoken advocate and educator for blockchain technology and the Bitcoin ecosystem. Read more on Bitcoin Magazine.

Riot Blockchain Buys 8,000 Next-Gen Antminer S19 Pros

Bitmain has announced that it inked a $17.7 million deal to provide 8,000 Bitmain Antminer S19 Pros to bitcoin mining company Riot Blockchain. The machines sport a hash rate of 110 TH/s with efficiency of 29.5±%5 J/TH, per the announcement. Riot believes that the acquisition will boost its total operational hash rate capacity to 1.45 EH/s across more than 15,000 miners.

FTX Acquires Blockfolio For $150 Million

Cryptocurrency derivatives exchange FTX has spent $150 million to acquire Blockfolio, a leading mobile crypto portfolio app. While FTX is positioned to attract professional traders, Blockfolio is more of a retail product, so the acquisition could help FTX reach a new audience.

Jerome Powell Set To Announce Higher Inflation Rate

U.S. Federal Reserve chairman Jerome Powell is reportedly planning to announce a more relaxed approach to managing price pressures, which could lead to higher long-term inflation. During tomorrow’s virtual version of the Fed’s annual conference in Wyoming, Powell plans to announce that the Fed will let inflation run higher than its pegged 2 percent, CNBC reported. Rampant fiat inflation is an issue that commonly drives people toward Bitcoin.

Jameson Lopp, WhalePanda Announce ICO

INX announced a regulated token sale this week with WhalePanda and Jameson Lopp showing support for the sale. While INX is clearly not a shitcoin, people were up in arms about the announcement for two reasons: First, this token is an ERC-20, which means, to some extent, endorsing the token is endorsing Ethereum’s security model, which is something that Bitcoiners generally tend to critique. Second, advisors to the project have upside in the token’s financial performance, which wasn’t clearly stated when they pointed attention to INX.

Now, is this worth all of the uproar that this announcement has received? Probably not. This doesn’t appear to be a worthless ICO token that they’re trying to dump on noobs. It’s received regulatory clearance to be listed, and clearly there is intent to make this genuinely valuable. It’s important for Bitcoiners to understand that, while bitcoin is the most valuable asset in the world, it isn’t the only asset in the world that has value. This appears to be an attempt at building a valuable asset; we’ll see how it goes.

Take Our Bitcoiner Survey And Earn Some Sats!

Through our partnership with the sat-earning platform Carrot, we're paying our readers to take a survey about the ways in which they use Bitcoin. It's quick, free and, best of all, it pays out in sats!