Support the Guardian

Fund independent journalism with £5 per month

Football Daily - The Guardian
Argentina get their celebrations on.
camera The throne, earlier. Power out of shot. Photograph: Mauro Pimentel/AFP/Getty Images
22/11/2023

Lionel Messi, harder men and an historic night of woe for Brazil

Will Unwin
 

THE MARACANÃ-WOE

There is a common mistake that is often committed when it comes to Argentina in that they are regularly referred to as Lionel Messi’s Argentina, a moniker that does disservice to the players who are really leading the team to new heights. On a night of aggression, fouls and police batons being swung with wild abandon at visiting supporters at the Maracanã, it was one of the true heroes, Nicolás Otamendi, who stepped up to inflict the very first home World Cup qualifying defeat on Brazil in their history.

To think that World Cups and Copa Américas are settled by forwards is naive. Goals win games but defences win championships, as any tea-time football email will tell you. Argentina have two of the hardest of hard men going at centre-back in the form of Otamendi and Cristian Romero, so to think Messi is more important than them is foolish. It took a pinpoint corner from Giovanni Lo Celso to find the former Manchester City man to settle the result in the 63rd minute. None of your dribbling and fancy skill that people seem so fond of.

Messi is the spin doctor of the team, the man who manipulates like no one else, seeing methods that others cannot to secure the desired result, but sometimes an iron fist is required. He approached the away section when police entered before kick-off with batons swinging and blood pouring, as he attempted to calm a situation that would delay the match by half an hour as some supporters sought sanctuary on the pitch. “This team continues to make history,” Messi later chirped. “Great victory at the Maracanã although it will be marked by the repression of Argentina fans once again in Brazil. This madness can’t be tolerated, and it has to end now!!” Messi did the talking while Emi Martínez, a man who knows a thing or two about an iron fist, took action by trying to stop a police officer brandishing a baton in the melee. One assumes the police backed down once they saw Otamendi and Romero giving them the stare.

Once a significant victory was secured after a tense night in Rio de Janeiro, there was another surprise in the post-match press conference when Lionel Scaloni announced he was considering quitting the world champions. “It’s not goodbye or anything, but I need to think because the bar is very high and it’s complicated to keep going and it’s complicated to keep winning,” tooted the former West Ham defender. A managerial departure can often disrupt a successful side, but few in Argentina will be worried with Otamendi and Romero producing the goods … and Messi doing bits and bobs. You can bring your fouls, batons and dinner because by the time La Albiceleste are done with you, you will need it.

LIVE ON BIG WEBSITE

Join Sarah Rendell from 8pm GMT for MBM updates from Eintracht Frankfurt 0-3 Barcelona in Women’s Big Cup.

 
Person Image

This is not the Black Friday message you think it is

We are proud to be funded by our readers rather than a billionaire owner or shareholders. This means we can continue to report with rigour and integrity on the events shaping our world.

Supporting the Guardian doesn’t need to be expensive. More than one million supporters believe this is important, and their generosity allows us to keep our journalism open to all. This Black Friday, we’re asking you to join them.

 

QUOTE OF THE DAY

“Last year I was very quick to compare my big brother Dr Mahamudu Bawumia to Harry Maguire. Mr Speaker, I now apologise. Today Mr Maguire has turned the corner and is a transformational footballer. Maguire is now scoring goals for Manchester United. Mr Speaker, Harry Maguire is now a key player for Manchester United. As for our ‘Maguire’ he is now roaming at the [International Monetary Fund] with a cup in hand. As for our economic Maguire, he is able to get pensioners to leave their homes and come and parade in the streets” – Ghanaian MP Isaac Adongo offers an apology to Harry Maguire in parliament for comments made about his competence. In 2022, Adongo compared the player to the vice-president, claiming Maguire “became the biggest threat at the centre of the Manchester United defence”. But like all good politicians, he has now backtracked on at least part of his condemnation.

Harry Maguire.
camera Everything’s coming up Harry. Ish. Photograph: Nikolay Doychinov/The FA/Getty Images

FOOTBALL DAILY LETTERS

quote

So, Manchester United players think their utter shambles this season is due to anything and anyone apart from themselves overworking in pre-season. It strikes me that an interesting thought experiment in the style of Schrödinger’s cat would be if you put a finite number of Manchester United players in a locked dressing room, how long it would take before just one of them achieved some degree of self-awareness and suggest that perhaps they are the problem? But then self-awareness isn’t their thing, although irony clearly is” – Noble Francis.

quote

Re: running up the score (Football Daily letters passim). Youth soccer here in the USA USA USA can be extremely one-sided. A common tactic I’ve observed coaches employing when they begin to run away with the result is to implement a pass restriction before shooting. I will hear the coach shouting something like ‘three passes before you can shoot’ or ‘we must have five passes before scoring’. As a parent on the sidelines, I wonder what is more insulting to the other team: running the score up or hearing the other coach shout those instructions? Losing heavily is one thing, but knowing that you are part of a game turned training session is another level of humiliation” – Stephen Jackson.

quote

I used to referee in the Catholic Youth League in Maryland, where the Mercy Rule applied. If a team took a seven-goal lead, they had to withdraw one player from the field. If their opponents reduced the lead, that player could come back on. I (and I alone) referred to it as the Sisters of Mercy Rule. Or, Law 18 – decreed by Mother Mary. Clear evidence the Football Gods exist” – Ian Plenderleith.

quote

In the cubs’ league as a boy, we played a team which included Murdo MacLeod (future Scotland, Celtic and Dortmund star), plus two other future professionals (one being his brother). I was our keeper and, after being 21-0 down at half-time, managed to keep the full-time score to a mere 28-0. Not due to any sporting let-up from them. The trick? In the first half there was a fence two yards behind the goal. In the second there was 50 yards of red blaes (no nets of course). My slow walk to retrieve the ball was a masterclass in game management. Oh, and did I mention the match was only 30 minutes each half?” – Gavin Stewart.

Send any letters to the.boss@theguardian.com. Today’s letter o’ the day winner is … Gavin Stewart, who lands a copy of Arsène Who? by Ryan Baldi. We’ve more to give away all week, so get typing.

RECOMMENDED LISTENING

The latest Women’s Football Weekly podcast is right here, right now.

The Guardian Podcasts

RECOMMENDED SHOPPING

Big Website’s peerless photographer, Tom Jenkins, has made some of his best images available to buy as limited-edition prints. Football highlights include Lionel Messi’s Human Rights World Cup triumph, the Lionesses celebrating at Wembley and Rodri hitting the back of the net in Big Cup final. Perfect for an early Christmas present. Take a look at the gallery and order your prints here.

THE ROAD TO WEMBLEY

Just when Horsham thought they were out, the FA Cup pulls them back in! Yes, the Isthmian League Premier outfit have been reinstated and will now travel to Sutton in round two, after Barnsley were unceremoniously booted out for fielding an ineligible player in their replay win. “We would like to apologise to our fans, players and staff for this regrettable error,” sighed a statement from the Tykes. “This mistake – although unintentional – falls way below the high standards we set at this club and is simply not what you deserve.”

Horsham fans
camera Next stop for Horsham fans: Sutton. Photograph: Every Second Media/Shutterstock

NEWS, BITS AND BOBS

The FA has revealed that clubs who pledged to improve their ethnic and gender diversity have collectively failed to hit any of their annual targets.

Celtic have been fined £15,200 after their fans waved Palestinian flags during their home match against Atlético Madrid last month in Glasgow.

The Euro 2024 playoffs await Wales after Croatia’s win over Armenia ensured a 1-1 draw with Turkey didn’t ultimately matter too much. Finland, Iceland or Ukraine will head to Cardiff on 21 March, with the winners playing Poland or Estonia five days later for a place at the tournament. “I don’t care, we’ll beat them all,” whooped Jordan James.

England boss Gareth Southgate is determined that there won’t be another Baden-Baden circus – you remember it – when England head to Germany next summer. “There is basically a [Uefa] catalogue and you’ve got to get in early on certain venues or you can try and go off the catalogue and do something different,” he cooed.

England players’ partners in Baden-Baden, 2006.
camera Iconic looks, earlier. Photograph: Chris Uncle/FilmMagic

Fresh off his vindication in Ghana, Harry Maguire has expressed despair at the number of “soft” and “ridiculous” penalties being awarded. “They are given for anything,” he fumed. “They are making life so hard for defenders to defend the way it should be.”

Splits among the Premier League 20 have been laid bare after a proposed ban on loans between associated clubs was defeated. Sigh.

And things aren’t getting any better for Germany after a 2-0 friendly defeat to Austria in which Leroy Sané was sent off. “The players are maybe playing not as freely as they could,” sniffed new coach Julian Nagelsmann. “We are not that unit that we are off the pitch. It is just missing on the pitch.”

STILL WANT MORE?

“Hope Sogni” is an AI-created hypothetical female Fifa presidential candidate. Confused? Let Suzanne Wrack explain.

Hope Sogni.
camera Photograph: Dark Horses; Twise.ai; Maggie Murphy

Jess King can play football, write music and perform spoken word pieces. She’s had a natter with Júlia Belas Trindade for Moving the Goalposts.

Symmetrical scores, European Cup clubs relegated and more. The Knowledge has the answer.

Belenenses are back, baby! Morgan Ofori on how they returned from oblivion.

Emma Hayes is a really exciting appointment for USA USA USA, so why is Gregg Berhalter still managing the men’s team? Graham Ruthven takes a look.

MEMORY LANE

A freezing January in south London forces Nottingham Forest’s Johnny Metgod to load up on the tights and gloves for their FA Cup tie with Crystal Palace at Selhurst Park. Not that they did him much good in a 1-0 defeat. How about that orange ball, though?

Johnny Metgod of Nottingham Forest in 1987
camera Photograph: Mark Leech/Offside/Getty Images

WELCOME FINLEY!

 

… there is a good reason why people choose not to support the Guardian.

Not everyone can afford to pay for the news right now. That's why we choose to keep our coverage of Westminster and beyond, open for everyone to read. If this is you, please continue to read for free.

Over the past 13 years, our investigative journalism exposing the shortcomings of Tory rule – austerity, Brexit, partygate - has resulted in resignations, apologies and policy corrections. And with an election just round the corner, we won’t stop now. It’s crucial that we can all make informed decisions about who is best to lead the UK.

Here are three good reasons to choose to support us today.

1

Our quality, investigative journalism is a scrutinising force at a time when the rich and powerful are getting away with more and more.

2

We are independent and have no billionaire owner controlling what we do, so your money directly powers our reporting.

3

It doesn’t cost much, and takes less time than it took to read this message.

Choose to power the Guardian’s journalism for years to come, whether with a small sum or a larger one. If you can, make the choice to support us on a monthly basis from just £2. It takes less than a minute to set up, and you can rest assured that you’re making a big impact every single month in support of open, independent journalism. Thank you.

 
Get in touch
If you have any questions or comments about any of our newsletters please email the.boss@theguardian.com
https://www.theguardian.com/uk
You are receiving this email because you are a subscriber to Football Daily. Guardian News & Media Limited - a member of Guardian Media Group PLC. Registered Office: Kings Place, 90 York Way, London, N1 9GU. Registered in England No. 908396