No, Israeli soldiers killed in Gaza are not martyrs
Opinion Editor's Choice
 
View in browser
 
 
This photo, provided by an American contractor, shows a woman slumped over in a donkey cart at a food distribution site in Gaza run by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation in June 2025
 
Molly Bernstein  
Molly Bernstein
 
 
With Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu visiting U.S. President Donald Trump in Washington D.C. this week, small slivers of optimism emerged for progress towards a cease-fire and hostage deal for the Gaza war. While the meeting between the two men has not yet led us to such an outcome – the political math seems relatively clear. Trump wants a Nobel Peace Prize, which he is more likely obtain if he succeeds in convincing Netanyahu to lay down his weapons in Gaza.

As Rachel Brandenburg of the Israel Policy Forum argues, Trump likely pushed Netanyahu in exactly this direction – to finally end the war. Here is one proposal from Mahmoud Shehada, a Palestinian living in Gaza, for what a cease-fire could look like. As Gershon Baskin, who previously negotiated IDF solder Gilad Shalit's release, reminds us the cost of continuing the war is too high.

Historian Joshua Leifer describes how Trump's means, although not his ends, signal a departure from the traditional bilateral relationship between Israel and the United States. From an American Jewish perspective, here is Rabbi Elliot Cosgrove of Manhattan's Park Avenue Synagogue on why now is the time to stand up and demand a cease-fire.

Here's a take by Saudi scholar Aziz Alghashian and Syria expert Rob Pinfold on how the Iran war may have precipitated less, instead of more, openness to normalization with Israel. Moty Kanias, formerly a senior executive in Israeli security agencies, argues that while Israel may have had some successes against Iran, the Islamic Republic too achieved many of its goals in the 12-day war.
 
 
 
 
podcast icon
PODCAST | 'Hope is a political choice': MK Gilad Kariv on the fight for democracy and Reform Judaism in Netanyahu's wartime Israel
 
LISTEN
 
 
 
 
 
People burn the representations of the U.S. and Israeli flags as a poster of the late Iranian revolutionary founder Ayatollah Khomeini is held at right during the funeral ceremony of Iranian armed forces generals, nuclear scientists and their family members killed in a 12-day war with Israel, in Tehran, Iran
 
 
Israel Won the War It Fought. But Iran Emerged Victorious in the One That Mattered
Moty Kanias | 09.07.2025
 
 
 
 
 
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, right, is greeted by U.S. President Donald Trump as he arrives at the West Wing of the White House in Washington
 
 
From AIPAC to Netanyahu: Does Trump Want to Re-shape U.S.-Israel Relations?
Joshua Leifer | 09.07.2025
 
 
 
 
 
Saudi Crown Prince and Prime Minister Mohammed bin Salman greets Emir of Qatar, Sheikh Tamim bin Hamad Al Thani, during the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) Summit, in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
 
 
Despite Netanyahu's Claims, Iran War Pushed the Saudis Away From Normalization, Not Closer
Aziz Alghashian | 09.07.2025
 
 
 
 
 
Demonstrators take part in a protest, to demand the immediate release of hostages held in Gaza since the October 7 attack on Israel by Hamas, in Tel Aviv
 
 
I Called on U.S. Jews Not to Protest Netanyahu. But Now We Must Stand for a Gaza Truce
Elliot Cosgrove | 09.07.2025
 
 
 
 
 
U.S. President Donald Trump smiles at Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu at the White House in Washington
 
 
Will Trump's Gaza Demands Overshadow Netanyahu's Iran Victory Lap in Washington?
Rachel Brandenburg | 09.07.2025
 
 
 
 
 
The funeral of Staff Sgt. Asaf Kafri, who was killed in Gaza
 
 
No, Israeli Soldiers Killed in Gaza Are Not Martyrs
Gershon Baskin | 09.07.2025
 
 
 
 
 
A person holds a placard with the face of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on a hand, as protestors gather at the entrance to Kibbutz Nir Oz, which is located near the Israel Gaza border and was attacked by Hamas on October 7
 
 
I Am a Palestinian Living in Gaza. This Is My Cease-fire Proposal to Israel
Mahmoud Shehada | 09.07.2025
 
 
Haaretz.com - הארץ
 
Facebook Twitter RSS Newsletter Apple Android
 
Unsubscribe from mailing list.
For more Haaretz newsletters, click here.
or contact support: digital-english@haaretz.co.il
Unsubscribe from all mailing lists
All rights reserved © Haaretz Daily Newspaper Ltd.
Schocken ­21, Tel - Aviv, ­6653207­, Israel.
Company Registration No. ­51-­001544-­9.