Plus, how the Deseret News has covered faith and religion for 175 years

With thanks to

Yale University Press

Deseret Logo
ChurchBeat
Wednesday, June 18, 2025
by tad walch

‘Picking God over the game’: Hear what players say who put missions before the big leagues

  

A recent story about a Latter-day Saint baseball fan and his father is the kind parents and grandparents will share for years.

 

Matthew Hutchings likes to collect autographed baseballs, the stuff of a young boy’s or girl’s biggest dreams. A player’s signature connects a collector — young or old — to a hero and the nostalgia for the game.

 

Hutchings hatched an amazing idea when he heard the former Major League Baseball player McKay Christensen talk about choosing to serve a mission over a $1 million offer to begin his professional baseball career.

 

The “Million-Dollar Missionary” led Hutchings to wonder how many Latter-day Saints had served missions and gone on to play Major League Baseball.

 

The answer is nine, the number of players you need to field a team. Of course it is. How can you not be romantic about baseball?

 

Hutchings played baseball at BYU and knew one of the returned missionary big leaguers, and they started to reach out. Hutchings stamped “Called to Serve” on some MLB balls and the players began to sign them.

 

So far, he has collected six of the nine autographs on a ball for himself. Each player includes his names, the location of his mission and the years he served.

 

“The story is the (nine) people, the small crowd of people who accomplished the feat of serving a mission and making it to the MLB,” Hutchings said. “And the ball is just kind of the physical piece of marrying my joy and love of baseball with The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.”

 

The big league RMs are signing nine other baseballs, one for each of them to keep.

 

But the real part that makes the link to the story worth bookmarking or sending to your friends is what the players say about their missions. Deseret News reporter Trent Wood spoke to several of them.

 

“My mission was something I felt called to do,” said Taylor Cole, who pitched for the Toronto Blue Jays and Los Angeles Angels. “No one had ever served a mission in my family. My parents were converts. I knew it would establish a foundation for the rest of my life, even if it came at the expense of a baseball career.”

 

“At the time, it was a hard choice — picking God over the game — but God knows best," former Seattle Mariner Jacob Hannemann said. “It was an incredible learning experience that taught me to put him first in my life before anything else, including myself. That decision led me to a lot of truth and personal growth.

 

“As much as I love baseball, I’ve come to see that there’s so much more to life than the game. I loved meeting people, helping them, and being part of something bigger than myself. I’m still deeply grateful to God for that experience, and I strive to put him first every single day. I’m thankful for where he led me then, and where he continues to lead me now.”

 

There’s so much from the players about their missions in the story.

 

And here are links to past Deseret News stories about each player:

  • McKay Christensen
  • Taylor Cole
  • Jeremy Guthrie
  • Jacob Hannemann
  • Matt Lindstrom
  • Justin Sterner
  • Brian Banks
  • Gary Johnson
  • Scott Nielsen

FROM YALE UNIVERSITY PRESS

From an award-winning biographer, a riveting and deeply researched portrait of Mormonism’s charismatic founder

 

In this vivid biography, John G. Turner presents Joseph Smith as a consummate religious entrepreneur and innovator. With insights from newly accessible diaries, Turner illuminates Smith’s stunning trajectory, from his beginnings as an uneducated, impoverished farmhand to one of the most successful religious leaders of nineteenth-century America.

My Recent Stories

 

How the Deseret News has covered faith and religion for 175 years (June 16)

 

11 new Latter-day Saint hymns include classic ‘Still, Still, Still’ and originals like, ‘I’m a Pioneer too’ (June 12)

About the Church

 

Elder Gary E. Stevenson of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles spent his Father’s Day testifying about Heavenly Father at the Antofagasta Chile Temple dedication on Sunday.

 

Read his dedicatory prayer here.

 

The second annual Religious Educators Conference included information about the mission, purpose and responsibility of the church’s religion teachers. Elder D. Todd Christofferson said the church’s religious educators should help students take personal ownership of their learning as they help develop lifelong disciples of Christ.

 

The First Presidency scheduled an Aug. 9 groundbreaking for the Winchester Virginia Temple.

What I’m Reading ... 

 

A BYU runner is the NCAA steeplechase champion. He also is a returned missionary.

 

Did you know a returned missionary is on one of the teams in the NBA Finals?

 

A boy lost his autographed-baseball collection when his house burned down. The ball that meant the most was the one he got his hero, Mike Trout, to sign before a game. Here’s how Trout responded when he learned about the fire. Hint: Trout autographed something else for his fan. (Paywall)

 

I’m grateful my summer nights are busy coaching softball right now so that I’m not ruminating about the Boston Red Sox trading one of my favorite players, Rafael Devers, to the San Francisco Giants. His nickname is “Carita,” which means baby face. You’ll understand if you click the link.

Deseret Logo

Download our free app for more news right from your pocket.

Behind the Scenes

AP02032802788

Los Angeles Dodgers' McKay Christensen rounds third to score on a double by Tom Goodwin in the sixth inning of an exhibition game against the Arizona Diamondbacks Thursday March 28, 2002 at Cashman Field in Las Vegas.

X
Facebook
Instagram
Website

Copyright © 2025 Deseret News Publishing Company, All rights reserved.

Deseret News Publishing Company, 55 N 300 W Ste 500, Salt Lake City, UT 84101

Manage preferences