‘Clubs are going to disappear’

The community game’s feedback for the Bills, Sweeney and Beaumont, makes for painful reading as RFU hits the road in week of Calcutta Cup

You may have noticed that the sports pages are less, well, sporty than they once were. There is rather more chance of reading stern-faced stories about Sir Jim Ratcliffe and the Glazers or Manchester City’s latest legal dispute than, say, the muddy winter joys of grassroots rugby union. It is the way of the modern world and, anyway, England playing Scotland in the Six Nations this Saturday is a bigger deal, right?

Well, yes and no. If you are counting the beans inside the Rugby Football Union’s offices in Twickenham there is barely a contest. The Six Nations annually bankrolls the rest of the domestic game: it is the commercial goose that lays the golden Gilbert‑shaped eggs. Never mind the scoreboard, let’s keep the corporate guests well fed and watered. It’s all about the bottom line.

In more modest clubhouses up and down the country everyone recognises this basic reality. Of course they do. Because, if they are to prosper themselves, they also have to keep the lights on, the pitches in order and the toilets working. In theory, all that money banked at the top of the pyramid filters down for the greater post-Covid good. In return the grassroots clubs keep rugby’s flame alight in places where RFU executives seldom tread.

Talk to the nation’s unpaid armies of volunteers, however, and the Calcutta Cup showpiece this weekend is a long way down their priority list. Recently the Whole Game Union, the organisation supporting around 250 dissident clubs that have forced the RFU to convene a special general meeting next month, sent out a survey asking for feedback. The replies amount to perhaps the loudest collective cry for help ever received from the shires.

The dissatisfaction dripping from the anonymised responses certainly seems intense. “The biggest issue is a fractured game … too many vested interests with no clear idea how to grow it,” a northern referees’ society writes. “Accept community rugby actually exists before it completely dies out,” a lower-tier club from East Anglia pleads. “The RFU is not in touch with the grassroots and is totally ignoring the problems it has. As [the] grassroots don’t bring in money, they write it off … yet it is the biggest membership of the RFU.”

On and on it goes: “poor leadership”, “disastrous RFU/Premiership dealings” and a “very poor player pathway system” are merely a fraction of the widespread grievances expressed, alongside cuts in travel cost assistance, Championship funding and shortcomings in communication. The fresh eight-year partnership with the Premiership clubs, costing around £264m, also remains a clear source of frustration. As another respondent put it: “The Premiership is being run as a cartel supported by the RFU. There is a complete disconnect between the top and the community game.”

Many are clearly anxious, not just for their own small parishes but for the wider club rugby family. Not so long ago, for example, Rochford Hundred in Essex ran eight adult men’s sides. Now they are down to three and their president, Ray Stephenson, has grown weary of what he perceives to be a lack of support from above.

“A lot of clubs in Essex now only run one men’s senior side. If there’s unavailability or injuries they’re crying off games. Clubs are going to disappear … we’ve already lost four in recent times. I would say community rugby is in a tricky position. The support mechanisms just aren’t there. The consistent complaint I hear is that Bill Sweeney and the RFU are more interested in corporates and wanting their money. It’s hard to find any strong evidence of where they’re supporting the community game to make it secure going forward.”

Stephenson also reckons some RFU officials are “living in cloud cuckoo land” when they seek to offset the falling numbers in adult male participation with healthier figures relating to women and girls. Locally he is further aggrieved with the mid-season administrative goalpost‑moving that could cause previously “safe” clubs to be relegated to a lower tier. It is just another of the concerns being encountered by Sweeney and the RFU’s interim chair, Sir Bill Beaumont, as they continue their nationwide “road show” aimed at fragmenting the SGM vote.

For many, though, it is too little too late with the furore over Sweeney’s pay – £742,000 basic salary plus a bonus of £348,000 in a year when the RFU reported an operating loss of almost £40m – still rippling through the cash-strapped community game. Stephenson says: “I have less of a problem with his salary in some respects but he’s taken a £348,000 bonus while making 42 staff redundant. Those people have got mortgages to pay and lives to lead. And, at a local level, we’re also the ones who suffer. It’s the kids I’m worried about. Where are they going to go and play their rugby? They don’t play it at many schools any more. They only play it with us or at other rugby clubs. It just makes me so cross.”

The RFU will point to the (reassuringly expensive) review conducted by the law firm Freshfields which found their “long-term incentive plan scheme” to be “appropriate in light of the goals it sought to achieve”. Such pieces of work, however, do not venture beyond their specific terms of reference and miss the nub of the issue generating so much anger and mistrust.

Among other things this one skated over the judgment of those in high office, their ability to read the room and the reality that they are effectively running a cooperative rather than some massive private corporation. And the biggest, most unforgivable aspect of all? The loss of yet another opportunity to write about the actual bloody sport.

Waiting for the great leap forward

So, no pressure on Matt Sherratt, Wales’s new interim coach. The Six Nations leaders Ireland are heading to Cardiff and the 47-year-old Sherratt has the coaching equivalent of a nanosecond in which to revive a side which has lost its opening two Six Nations games. Then again, what an opportunity. If he can breathe instant fresh life into a Welsh side still coming to terms with the sudden departure of Warren Gatland then he might yet merit consideration for a more permanent role. Which would be quite an achievement for an Englishman born and raised across the border in Gloucester. Should a rejuvenated Wales see off their neighbours in the Principality Stadium next month it will certainly rank among the greatest Lazarus-style comebacks in Six Nations history.

Memory lane

At the start of the millennium, England were on a roll, coming into the match against Scotland eyeing a grand slam only to be, well, you know, sent homewards. On a day when it felt like the Murrayfield pitch was rapidly turning into a lake, Duncan Hodge controlled the show in the second-half amid a Scotland comeback. By the end of the match, Hodge boasted a try, four penalties and a conversion and the hosts had finally secured a victory after four inaugural Six Nations defeats, winning 19-13. England won the championship regardless, but the anguish was palpable after a second successive grand slam was lost at the final hurdle.

One to watch

England v Scotland will be fascinating for all sorts of reasons. Scotland cannot afford to be as ineffectual as they were made to look in the first half against Ireland. England will want to show that their thrilling late win against France was no fluke and their recent record in this fixture – just one win in their past seven Calcutta Cup outings home and away – also needs bolstering. With British & Irish Lions tour places also up for grabs, it has the ingredients to be another belter.

Still want more?

Ugo Monye gives his half-term report on the Six Nations with Ireland topping the class yet again.

An attempt by London Irish to leave the English system and join the United Championship is set to be blocked, reports Matt Hughes.

And Paul MacInnes reports on the increased pessimism of government official over the financial stability of rugby union.

Subscribe

To subscribe to the Breakdown, just visit this page and follow the instructions.

And sign up for The Recap, the best of our sports writing from the past seven days.